New look of Jallianwala Bagh a distortion of history, say historians
ECONOMY & POLICY

New look of Jallianwala Bagh a distortion of history, say historians

The new look of the Jallianwala Bagh memorial that Prime Minister Narendra Modi dedicated to the nation on August 28 has distorted the site's history. Historians said on Monday that British troops massacred Indians on 13 April 1919.

Modi inaugurated four new galleries virtually and opened the renovated memorial a year-and-a-half after it was closed for the revamp. When the forces directed by Reginald Dyer opened fire, victims jumped into a well which has been covered with a transparent barrier. The narrow entrance was adorned with sculptures. A daily sound and light show has started explaining the events.

Historian and former Jawaharlal Nehru University professor Chaman Lal told the media reacting to the development that it was a distortion of history and the project tried to mystify and glamourise history.

Professor Lal said that people visiting should go with a sense of pain and anguish, and now they have tried to make it a space for enjoying, with a beautiful garden, and it was not a beautiful garden. Instead, Jallianwala Bagh was where Indians gathered on that fateful day when Dyer and his forces entered and fired on a peaceful crowd. The government has renovated the place, adding new features instead of restoration.

Historian S Irfan Habib told the media that he was not against additions like a cafe for visitors or better toilets, but the changes made had been at the cost of history and the cost of heritage.

He emphasised that it was absolutely gaudy and asked why there should be murals on the wall as it changes the whole idea of the place from where Dyer entered to kill and adding glamour to the little corridor changes the entire visual history, and that history itself is being re-written and renovated, and it is the corporatisation of monuments.

He said that the well was not supposed to be covered and the changes were unnecessary and cosmetic in nature and that it is an unfortunate trend.

Image Source

The new look of the Jallianwala Bagh memorial that Prime Minister Narendra Modi dedicated to the nation on August 28 has distorted the site's history. Historians said on Monday that British troops massacred Indians on 13 April 1919. Modi inaugurated four new galleries virtually and opened the renovated memorial a year-and-a-half after it was closed for the revamp. When the forces directed by Reginald Dyer opened fire, victims jumped into a well which has been covered with a transparent barrier. The narrow entrance was adorned with sculptures. A daily sound and light show has started explaining the events. Historian and former Jawaharlal Nehru University professor Chaman Lal told the media reacting to the development that it was a distortion of history and the project tried to mystify and glamourise history. Professor Lal said that people visiting should go with a sense of pain and anguish, and now they have tried to make it a space for enjoying, with a beautiful garden, and it was not a beautiful garden. Instead, Jallianwala Bagh was where Indians gathered on that fateful day when Dyer and his forces entered and fired on a peaceful crowd. The government has renovated the place, adding new features instead of restoration. Historian S Irfan Habib told the media that he was not against additions like a cafe for visitors or better toilets, but the changes made had been at the cost of history and the cost of heritage. He emphasised that it was absolutely gaudy and asked why there should be murals on the wall as it changes the whole idea of the place from where Dyer entered to kill and adding glamour to the little corridor changes the entire visual history, and that history itself is being re-written and renovated, and it is the corporatisation of monuments. He said that the well was not supposed to be covered and the changes were unnecessary and cosmetic in nature and that it is an unfortunate trend. Image Source

Next Story
Equipment

Godrej Material Handling Leads East India with 21% Market Share

The Material Handling business of Godrej & Boyce, a part of Godrej Enterprises Group, is powering industrial growth in Eastern India marking over 60 per cent Y-o-Y growth in the Jamshedpur region for FY25. Solidifying its market leadership, the business commands a dominant 21 per cent market share in the Eastern region, serving as a crucial enabler for the region’s manufacturing sector. At the Indomach Expo in Jamshedpur, the business is showcasing its next-generation forklift to meet evolving needs of Eastern India’s industrial corridor. Jamshedpur, Eastern India’s industrial po..

Next Story
Equipment

Mecbo America Launches Scorpion Concrete Crawler Boom

Mecbo America, a division of Blastcrete Equipment LLC, brings a new product to its lineup: the Scorpion Concrete Crawler Boom. The Scorpion provides contractors working in piling, drilling, tunnelling or commercial construction with a flexible arm for placing concrete where needed without disrupting the jobsite. It is an economical enhancement for contractors who have a concrete pump but need an effective way to deftly move material to spots that are difficult or unsafe to reach using other methods.“As concrete contractors grow and the scope of their work changes, many recognize the need for..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

REC Flags off Mobile Medical Units Funded in Punjab

REC Limited, a Maharatna CPSE under the Ministry of Power and a leading NBFC, under its flagship CSR initiative Mobile Medical Units has committed Rs 42.9 million for the procurement and deployment of four Mobile Medical Units (MMUs) in 4 districts of Punjab. These units, handed over to the Indian Red Cross Society, Punjab, were flagged off by Hon’ble Governor Shri Gulab Chand Kataria Ji at Punjab Raj Bhawan.Serving as a lifeline for deprived communities, the MMUs will provide essential healthcare across four districts. REC Foundation continues to expand its CSR footprint, with various Mobil..

Advertisement

Advertisement

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get daily newsletters around different themes from Construction world.

STAY CONNECTED

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement

Talk to us?