New look of Jallianwala Bagh a distortion of history, say historians
ECONOMY & POLICY

New look of Jallianwala Bagh a distortion of history, say historians

The new look of the Jallianwala Bagh memorial that Prime Minister Narendra Modi dedicated to the nation on August 28 has distorted the site's history. Historians said on Monday that British troops massacred Indians on 13 April 1919.

Modi inaugurated four new galleries virtually and opened the renovated memorial a year-and-a-half after it was closed for the revamp. When the forces directed by Reginald Dyer opened fire, victims jumped into a well which has been covered with a transparent barrier. The narrow entrance was adorned with sculptures. A daily sound and light show has started explaining the events.

Historian and former Jawaharlal Nehru University professor Chaman Lal told the media reacting to the development that it was a distortion of history and the project tried to mystify and glamourise history.

Professor Lal said that people visiting should go with a sense of pain and anguish, and now they have tried to make it a space for enjoying, with a beautiful garden, and it was not a beautiful garden. Instead, Jallianwala Bagh was where Indians gathered on that fateful day when Dyer and his forces entered and fired on a peaceful crowd. The government has renovated the place, adding new features instead of restoration.

Historian S Irfan Habib told the media that he was not against additions like a cafe for visitors or better toilets, but the changes made had been at the cost of history and the cost of heritage.

He emphasised that it was absolutely gaudy and asked why there should be murals on the wall as it changes the whole idea of the place from where Dyer entered to kill and adding glamour to the little corridor changes the entire visual history, and that history itself is being re-written and renovated, and it is the corporatisation of monuments.

He said that the well was not supposed to be covered and the changes were unnecessary and cosmetic in nature and that it is an unfortunate trend.

Image Source

Redefine the future of urban mobility! Join us at the Metro Rail Conference 2025 to explore groundbreaking ideas and insights. 👉 Register today!

The new look of the Jallianwala Bagh memorial that Prime Minister Narendra Modi dedicated to the nation on August 28 has distorted the site's history. Historians said on Monday that British troops massacred Indians on 13 April 1919. Modi inaugurated four new galleries virtually and opened the renovated memorial a year-and-a-half after it was closed for the revamp. When the forces directed by Reginald Dyer opened fire, victims jumped into a well which has been covered with a transparent barrier. The narrow entrance was adorned with sculptures. A daily sound and light show has started explaining the events. Historian and former Jawaharlal Nehru University professor Chaman Lal told the media reacting to the development that it was a distortion of history and the project tried to mystify and glamourise history. Professor Lal said that people visiting should go with a sense of pain and anguish, and now they have tried to make it a space for enjoying, with a beautiful garden, and it was not a beautiful garden. Instead, Jallianwala Bagh was where Indians gathered on that fateful day when Dyer and his forces entered and fired on a peaceful crowd. The government has renovated the place, adding new features instead of restoration. Historian S Irfan Habib told the media that he was not against additions like a cafe for visitors or better toilets, but the changes made had been at the cost of history and the cost of heritage. He emphasised that it was absolutely gaudy and asked why there should be murals on the wall as it changes the whole idea of the place from where Dyer entered to kill and adding glamour to the little corridor changes the entire visual history, and that history itself is being re-written and renovated, and it is the corporatisation of monuments. He said that the well was not supposed to be covered and the changes were unnecessary and cosmetic in nature and that it is an unfortunate trend. Image Source

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

Shiv Murti-Nelson Mandela Tunnel Faces Environmental Concerns

Residents of South Delhi have raised concerns over the proposed tunnel between Shiv Murti interchange on NH-48 and Nelson Mandela Marg in Vasant Kunj, fearing it could harm the local forest, environment, and potentially damage houses in the area. The Delhi Pollution Control Committee (DPCC) presented these concerns in a report to the Union Environment Ministry, following public hearings conducted in September. The ministry will decide whether to grant environmental clearance for the project, with construction slated to begin in July 2025. The tunnel, planned by the National Highways Authorit..

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

Government Plans Metro Expansion in Hyderabad's North City

The residents of North Hyderabad are set to benefit from the Telangana government's plan to expand the city's metro network to Medchal and Shamirpet. Chief Minister Revanth Reddy has instructed officials to prepare Detailed Project Reports (DPRs) for two new metro corridors as part of this major expansion project. As per the CM's directive, the DPRs must be completed quickly and incorporated into Phase-2B of the metro project. Once finalised, the reports will be submitted to the central government for approval. The proposed extensions include: Extending the metro line from Paradise to Medchal...

Next Story
Infrastructure Transport

BRS Calls for Revival of Raidurg to Shamshabad Metro Corridor

BRS leaders have urged the Telangana government to reinstate the metro rail corridor from Raidurg to Shamshabad, a project originally proposed by the previous BRS administration. They also requested the establishment of a clear deadline for completing Phase II of the metro project, particularly the northern city stretches. Additionally, they suggested implementing a double-decker metro system for the Jubilee Bus Station to Shamirpet corridor. During a press conference at Telangana Bhavan, BRS MLAs KP Vivekananda and Marri Rajasekhar Reddy, along with former MPs Balka Suman and B Vinod Kumar, ..

Hi There!

"Now get regular updates from CW Magazine on WhatsApp!

Join the CW WhatsApp channel for the latest news, industry events, expert insights, and project updates from the construction and infrastructure industry.

Click the link below to join"

+91 81086 03000