Bombay HC directs state to vacate Dadar flat in 20-year rent dispute
Real Estate

Bombay HC directs state to vacate Dadar flat in 20-year rent dispute

The Bombay High Court stated that while mathematical precision is not required for regular rent payments, this does not imply that the State could avoid its obligations to pay rent for months or even years during the duration of an eviction suit. The court upheld the Small Causes Court's orders to return a flat located in a prime area of Dadar to its landlord.

This ruling concluded a 20-year eviction dispute by directing the State and the Mumbai police commissioner, listed as the tenant on the rent receipts, to vacate the flat by the end of November.

The monthly rent for the spacious 800 sq ft flat was Rs 396.75. The government had utilized the flat for many years as official accommodation for police officers, with the court being informed that a police officer—not the police commissioner—was residing there.

The courts determined that there had been no sub-letting, as claimed by the late landlord, Dilipkumar Purandare; however, the issue of unpaid rent remained.

Justice Sandeep Marne of the High Court ruled on a plea filed by the State and the police chief in response to a Small Causes appellate court judgment from November 2023, affirming that the Maharashtra government was in arrears for rent. He criticized the government for its "negligent approach" and noted that it failed to utilise the legal provision that allows for the regular deposit of rent in court when the landlord filed an eviction suit in 2004.

The court emphasized that the government did not comply with the provisions of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act by failing to deposit the overdue rent, interest, and legal costs within 90 days of the service of the suit summons. Furthermore, it did not continue to make regular rent deposits in court. This conclusion was reached after hearing arguments from government lawyer A R Patil and the landlord's counsel, Nusrat Shah.

In 2016, the Small Causes Court had accepted the landlord's plea regarding the bona fide need for the flat due to his expanding family and the issue of unpaid rent. The State then appealed to the Small Causes appellate bench, which in 2023 acknowledged the State's argument that the landlord had not proven a "bona fide requirement." Nevertheless, it upheld the eviction order based on the unpaid rent arrears, leading the State to challenge this decision in the High Court. Shah contended that the State had not paid rent arrears since December 1, 1989.

The Bombay High Court stated that while mathematical precision is not required for regular rent payments, this does not imply that the State could avoid its obligations to pay rent for months or even years during the duration of an eviction suit. The court upheld the Small Causes Court's orders to return a flat located in a prime area of Dadar to its landlord. This ruling concluded a 20-year eviction dispute by directing the State and the Mumbai police commissioner, listed as the tenant on the rent receipts, to vacate the flat by the end of November. The monthly rent for the spacious 800 sq ft flat was Rs 396.75. The government had utilized the flat for many years as official accommodation for police officers, with the court being informed that a police officer—not the police commissioner—was residing there. The courts determined that there had been no sub-letting, as claimed by the late landlord, Dilipkumar Purandare; however, the issue of unpaid rent remained. Justice Sandeep Marne of the High Court ruled on a plea filed by the State and the police chief in response to a Small Causes appellate court judgment from November 2023, affirming that the Maharashtra government was in arrears for rent. He criticized the government for its negligent approach and noted that it failed to utilise the legal provision that allows for the regular deposit of rent in court when the landlord filed an eviction suit in 2004. The court emphasized that the government did not comply with the provisions of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act by failing to deposit the overdue rent, interest, and legal costs within 90 days of the service of the suit summons. Furthermore, it did not continue to make regular rent deposits in court. This conclusion was reached after hearing arguments from government lawyer A R Patil and the landlord's counsel, Nusrat Shah. In 2016, the Small Causes Court had accepted the landlord's plea regarding the bona fide need for the flat due to his expanding family and the issue of unpaid rent. The State then appealed to the Small Causes appellate bench, which in 2023 acknowledged the State's argument that the landlord had not proven a bona fide requirement. Nevertheless, it upheld the eviction order based on the unpaid rent arrears, leading the State to challenge this decision in the High Court. Shah contended that the State had not paid rent arrears since December 1, 1989.

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

NBCC bags construction order worth Rs 5 Bn

NBCC India said it has bagged a construction order worth Rs 5 billion from the Bureau of Indian Standards. As per the order, NBCC will construct buildings at BIS headquarters in New Delhi, central laboratory, Sahibabad, National Institute of Training for standardisation, Noida, Northern Regional Laboratory, Mohali and Bangalore Branch Laboratory, Bengaluru. On Monday, November 4, the company said its subsidiary Hindustan Steelworks Construction Ltd (HSCL) bagged work orders worth Rs 650 million in Bengaluru. As per the order, Hindustan Steelworks Construction will undertake development work o..

Next Story
Infrastructure Urban

India formally sent LoI to host 2036 Olympics

India took a significant step toward potentially hosting the 2036 Olympic and Paralympic Games. On October 1st, the Indian Olympic Association (IOA) officially submitted a Letter of Intent to the International Olympic Committee's (IOC) Future Host Commission, sources told news agency IANS. This action follows repeated expressions of interest from Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who sees the Games as a potential boon for the nation. "Prime Minister Narendra Modi's vision of hosting the Olympic and Paralympic Games in India in 2036 has taken a significant step forward," a source stated. Th..

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

NTPC, ONGC collaborate on green energy

In a significant move towards renewable energy, Maharatna PSUs NTPC and ONGC have partnered to form a 50:50 Joint Venture Company (JVC) through their respective green energy subsidiaries, NTPC Green Energy Ltd. (NGEL) and ONGC Green Energy Ltd. (OGL). The collaboration aims to expand their footprint in the renewable energy sector, encompassing a range of green technologies and projects, from solar and wind energy to green hydrogen and sustainable aviation fuel. The formal Joint Venture Agreement was signed on February 7, 2024, during India Energy Week, followed by approvals from the Departmen..

Hi There!

"Now get regular updates from CW Magazine on WhatsApp!

Join the CW WhatsApp channel for the latest news, industry events, expert insights, and project updates from the construction and infrastructure industry.

Click the link below to join"

+91 81086 03000