Controversial Law Sparks Mining Debate
COAL & MINING

Controversial Law Sparks Mining Debate

Indonesia's new law granting mining permits to religious groups has ignited a firestorm of controversy. Critics argue it could lead to environmental degradation and social discord, while proponents claim it promotes equitable resource distribution.

The legislation, recently passed by Indonesia's parliament, allows religious organisations to engage in mining activities. Proponents assert that this move empowers local communities and ensures fairer distribution of mining revenues. They argue it could uplift impoverished regions where these religious groups operate, providing much-needed economic opportunities and infrastructure development.

However, the law has faced significant opposition from environmentalists and civil society organisations. They warn of potential ecological damage, pointing to Indonesia's already vulnerable ecosystems. Critics also fear that the law could lead to increased conflict, as religious groups might clash over valuable mining territories. Concerns about transparency and corruption have also been raised, given Indonesia's complex regulatory environment.

Environmental activists are particularly vocal, highlighting the risk of deforestation, water pollution, and loss of biodiversity. They argue that religious groups, often lacking in technical expertise, might prioritise short-term economic gains over long-term environmental sustainability. The potential for religious tension adds another layer of complexity, as disputes over mining rights could exacerbate existing social fractures.

Human rights organisations have expressed worries about the displacement of indigenous communities. These groups often live in areas rich in natural resources, and without adequate protections, they might be forcibly removed from their lands. There are calls for stricter regulatory oversight to ensure that any mining activities conducted by religious organisations adhere to environmental and social safeguards.

The government defends the legislation, stating it includes provisions for environmental protection and community development. Officials argue that involving religious groups could lead to more ethical and community-focused mining practices. They stress that the law is designed to benefit the nation's most disadvantaged communities.

As Indonesia navigates this controversial path, the balance between economic development, environmental conservation, and social harmony remains precarious. The true impact of this legislation will unfold in the coming years, shaping the country's socio-economic landscape.

Indonesia's new law granting mining permits to religious groups has ignited a firestorm of controversy. Critics argue it could lead to environmental degradation and social discord, while proponents claim it promotes equitable resource distribution. The legislation, recently passed by Indonesia's parliament, allows religious organisations to engage in mining activities. Proponents assert that this move empowers local communities and ensures fairer distribution of mining revenues. They argue it could uplift impoverished regions where these religious groups operate, providing much-needed economic opportunities and infrastructure development. However, the law has faced significant opposition from environmentalists and civil society organisations. They warn of potential ecological damage, pointing to Indonesia's already vulnerable ecosystems. Critics also fear that the law could lead to increased conflict, as religious groups might clash over valuable mining territories. Concerns about transparency and corruption have also been raised, given Indonesia's complex regulatory environment. Environmental activists are particularly vocal, highlighting the risk of deforestation, water pollution, and loss of biodiversity. They argue that religious groups, often lacking in technical expertise, might prioritise short-term economic gains over long-term environmental sustainability. The potential for religious tension adds another layer of complexity, as disputes over mining rights could exacerbate existing social fractures. Human rights organisations have expressed worries about the displacement of indigenous communities. These groups often live in areas rich in natural resources, and without adequate protections, they might be forcibly removed from their lands. There are calls for stricter regulatory oversight to ensure that any mining activities conducted by religious organisations adhere to environmental and social safeguards. The government defends the legislation, stating it includes provisions for environmental protection and community development. Officials argue that involving religious groups could lead to more ethical and community-focused mining practices. They stress that the law is designed to benefit the nation's most disadvantaged communities. As Indonesia navigates this controversial path, the balance between economic development, environmental conservation, and social harmony remains precarious. The true impact of this legislation will unfold in the coming years, shaping the country's socio-economic landscape.

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

India urges states to consider nuclear power plants, lists utilities

India’s federal power minister urged states distant from coal resources to explore establishing nuclear-based power plants, in addition to identifying power utilities that could attract investment to support the rising energy demand. This year, the Indian government proposed in its federal budget a partnership with private entities to develop small nuclear reactors, aiming to boost electricity generation from sources that do not emit carbon dioxide. In a government statement, the power minister, Manohar Lal, advised states to consider setting up nuclear power plants at locations where coal..

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

NTPC Green Energy sets price range for $1.2 billion IPO

NTPC Green Energy announced a price range of Rs 102 to 108 per share for its upcoming Rs 100 billion initial public offering (IPO). The renewable energy company’s IPO will open for bids on November 19 and close on November 22, with large "anchor" investors scheduled to bid on November 18. This IPO, a unit of the state-owned NTPC, is set to be the third-largest stock offering in the country this year, following those of Hyundai Motor India and Swiggy. Recent technological advancements have opened up possibilities for small wind turbines to function effectively in urban settings. Ministry of N..

Next Story
Infrastructure Energy

India considers small wind turbines for urban energy access

India’s carbon emissions are projected to increase by 4.6 per cent in 2024, accounting for 8 per cent of global emissions, as reported by the Global Carbon Project in its 2024 Global Carbon Budget. The report shows that global fossil CO2 emissions have reached a record high of 37.4 billion tonnes this year, marking a 0.8% per cent rise from 2023. When combined with emissions from land-use changes, including deforestation, the total CO2 emissions are expected to hit 41.6 billion tonnes, up from 40.6 billion tonnes in 2023. India’s rising emissions reflect an increasing demand for energy, w..

Hi There!

"Now get regular updates from CW Magazine on WhatsApp!

Join the CW WhatsApp channel for the latest news, industry events, expert insights, and project updates from the construction and infrastructure industry.

Click the link below to join"

+91 81086 03000